Valerio's Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Rick Maselli a month ago

We discovered Valerios several years ago after going to Presque Isle over and over again and each year we come back. This year it was no difference. The pizza was delicious. The salad was great and the Italian redis fantastic. I highly recommend that you try this place!!!

Lisa Burford 2 months ago

The atmosphere is comfortable and quaint, and the service was wonderful! But the food was over the top! Fresh, authentic flavor, cooked to perfection! I ordered chicken parmesian and fettuccine Alfredo with a side salad. (BTW the rumors about the ranch are true!l) That ranch dressing was top notch !! The best !! The fettuccine noodles were al dente! Perfect! The sauce was so creamy (it was dreamy)! The chicken parmesian was also perfect, with the outer crunchy layer topped with home made sauce and cheese. The chicken was and tender and juicy and cooked well! Also I tried one meatball. Its everything I had hoped to experience and it was about 2 in diameter. It was very, very, good as well!! I couldn't believe how good the whole meal was and for about $20!! How reasonable are the prices! Thank you Valerio's! For a great meal, authentic, while away from home!

Roni Sprouse 3 months ago

We were passing through Erie PA and asked the clerk at the front desk for local food recommendations. He could not have pointed us to a better restaurant. The food was beyond fantastic!!! Homemade pasta in the richest, most delicious sauces! My husband had spaghetti and meatballs, which he said was the very best he ever had! I had chicken florentin. AMAZING! My only regret is that I couldn't finish it all. If you ever have a chance to come here, I recommend you do.

Louis 5 months ago

Valerio's Italian GOOD: Nearly everything - my pizza rolls were delicious, the seafood alfredo hit the spot - great service and warm decor that brought back memories of the childhood corner Italian place BAD: Nothing much, the pasta was slightly over cooked (didn't effect my enjoyment) The place gets a little hectic as it fills but the staff does a good job. I was very pleased with Valerio's. After several Italian places fell flat since visiting, Valerio's was a win. It's a warm, family place with hearty food and great service. I can't wait to go back and try a calzone or pizza.

Stephany M a year ago

The atmosphere was great, the dining area is a little small but the little touches like the real flowers at the tables was nice. We loved there sauce it wasn't to sweet, there bread was delicious, and all the appetizers were great. The little pan pizza was a little to doughy, the Italian wedding soup was delicious but way to much pasta, the wings had mild sauce on them and it was really tangy (good but not what i am use to), and i got a turkey on rye sandwich that really could have used more flavor on it. I would defently go back.